Menu

Cooley Obtains Summary Judgment for Qualcomm in Patent Infringement Lawsuit

Firm’s IP litigation team has successfully defended Qualcomm against 22 ParkerVision patents spread across four cases

Washington, DC – April 5, 2022 – Cooley achieved a significant victory for longtime client Qualcomm when US District Judge Paul G. Byron of the US District Court for the Middle District of Florida granted the firm’s motion for summary judgment in a contested patent infringement lawsuit, ParkerVision v. Qualcomm. Lawyers Stephen Smith, Matthew Brigham, Eamonn Gardner, Dena Chen, Jeffrey Karr, Priya Viswanath and Benjamin Lin led the Cooley team advising Qualcomm. Brigham and Gardner argued the motion for summary judgment, with assistance from the larger team.

The case was the latest of several infringement lawsuits filed over a 10-year span by ParkerVision against Qualcomm involving chips found in most smartphones sold in the US. The lawsuit initially alleged infringement of 11 patents, but over the course of eight years, Cooley defeated eight of the patents, and prevailed in a separate US International Trade Commission investigation involving four more patents. These results are in addition to Cooley previously obtaining a motion for judgment as a matter of law of noninfringement, as well as a favorable ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on noninfringement and invalidity for four other ParkerVision patents in the first lawsuit between the parties. Including this most recent ruling, Cooley has successfully defended Qualcomm against 22 ParkerVision patents spread across four cases.

The last three patents in this case fell on March 23 after Judge Byron issued two orders granting summary judgment of noninfringement of all remaining patents and striking key testimony of ParkerVision’s technical expert. Instead of a trial later this year, judgment was entered in Qualcomm’s favor on all causes of action.

With 60+ litigators across the US and Europe, Cooley’s intellectual property litigation practice group routinely handles IP disputes involving core technologies, products and brands. The team is renowned for its ability to win bet-the-company competitor cases with billions of dollars at stake, and has unprecedented experience representing clients in technology and life sciences matters. Some of Cooley’s recent and notable IP litigation victories include securing a summary judgment win for longtime client Facebook, now known as Meta Platforms, in a patent infringement lawsuit involving customer engagement technology, which earned runner-up distinction from The American Lawyer’s Litigation Daily Litigator of the Week list, as well as defeating a motion for preliminary injunction filed by Reputation.com seeking to ban Cooley client Birdeye’s leading business-to-business reputation management products.

About Cooley LLP

Clients partner with Cooley on transformative deals, complex IP and regulatory matters, and high-stakes litigation, where innovation meets the law.

Cooley has 1,500 lawyers across 17 offices in the United States, Asia and Europe.

Related Contacts
Stephen Smith  Partner Washington, DC, Reston
Matthew Brigham  Partner Palo Alto
Eamonn Gardner  Partner Colorado
Dena Chen  Partner Palo Alto
Jeffrey Karr  Partner Palo Alto
Priya B. Viswanath  Special Counsel Palo Alto
Benjamin S. Lin  Associate Palo Alto
Stephen Neal  Chairman Emeritus Palo Alto
Kathleen Goodhart  Partner San Francisco
Erin Trenda  Partner San Diego
David Murdter  Associate Palo Alto
Rich Nieva  Senior Paralegal Palo Alto
Cassandra Reed  Paralegal Specialist Palo Alto