Mervyn's LLC, et al. v. Lubert-Adler Group, IV, LLC, et al.

Case in Point

Overview

Cooley represented the official committee of unsecured creditors for Mervyn's and its estate in a highly contentious bankruptcy litigation the committee brought against various private equity firms, financial institutions and others that acquired Mervyn's from Target Corp. in a September 2004 LBO transaction. The acquirers were accused of transferring Mervyn's real estate to entities they controlled which were beyond the reach of creditors. The funds were also accused of raising Mervyn's rent, as well as extracting hundreds of millions of dollars in management fees and dividends.

Results

The settlement will allow the Mervyn’s estate to cover $93 million in unpaid administrative claims.

The Mervyn’s estate was able to confirm a liquidation plan in March 2013 with material recovery for unsecured creditors owed approximately $400 million.


Mervyn’s was a moderate-price department store chain that filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in July 2008. At the time of the filing, the company operated 175 stores across California and the Southwestern United States. It employed 18,000 people and had reported sales of $2.5 billion.

Cooley represented the official committee of unsecured creditors for Mervyn’s and its estate in a highly contentious bankruptcy litigation the committee brought against various private equity firms, financial institutions and others that acquired Mervyn’s from Target Corp. in a September 2004 LBO transaction. Cooley, on behalf of the estate and the committee, prosecuted fraudulent transfer, preference and breach of fiduciary duty causes of action against Mervyn’s acquirers that concerned asset stripping in a sophisticated OPCO/PROPCO scheme.

Four years after the suit was filed, Cooley secured a settlement that was approved in November 2012 by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. The terms of the settlement required the defendants to transfer a very significant amount of money to the Mervyn’s estate through the release of escrowed funds and additional cash and to waive hundreds of millions of dollars of claims against the estate. In exchange, all litigation was dismissed. During the confirmation hearing, The Honorable Kevin Gross said of the attorneys at Cooley, “…I knew the case was in good hands because all the cases in which you’ve been involved have been handled so professionally and so effectively…. I know it was a very difficult case, and you really – you really did make yourselves proud....”

Download PDF

Cooley Team
Jay Indyke Partner, New York
Cathy Hershcopf Partner, New York
Ian Shapiro Partner, New York
Seth Van Aalten Partner, New York
Related Practices & Industries

Business Restructuring & Reorganization